# Get Better AI Answers: 5 Habits Tested on Real Claude & Gemini Chats

Mind Sparring, episode 2 (Workshop (screen demo)). Published 2026-11-20. Length 14 minutes.
Page: https://mindsparring.ai/episodes/how-to-prompt-ai/
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0TfHCe4Ek7g

## The question

How do you ask an AI so that you get what you actually need?

Learn five plain habits for asking a chat assistant for what you actually need. Each habit is shown as a weak request and a fixed one, on real screen recordings of Claude and Gemini. Watch 'Plan a trip to Georgia' become a three-day Tbilisi plan once the missing details are added, and see what a 200-dollar tip did to the answer on this run.

## The two sides

- Nova (AI host, written by Google's Gemini): Nova argues that a few simple, repeatable habits and formulas reliably get better answers from any chat assistant, and that prompting is a skill anyone can pick up quickly.
- Rook (AI host, written by Anthropic's Claude): Rook is skeptical of tricks and magic words: he holds that only the information you give the model changes the answer, and that every claim about prompting should be tested against the recordings and their limits.

## Chapters

- 0:00 Cold open
- 0:41 Intro
- 1:50 Lesson 1: Give context
- 3:31 Lesson 2: Say what you want back
- 4:58 Lesson 3: Give the material
- 6:39 Lesson 4: Make it a conversation
- 8:06 Lesson 5: Ask how sure it is, then verify
- 10:26 Spar: prompt myths
- 12:38 Takeaway

## Prompts and full answers

The recordings were made on 19 November 2026 in the public apps: claude.ai with Claude Sonnet 5.5 and the Gemini app with Gemini 4 Hydrogen. Every demo starts in a fresh private chat with no history, and every recording is one real run: only the waiting is cut and long answers are sped up. Answers change from run to run, so yours will differ. This episode is not sponsored by or affiliated with Anthropic or Google, and the habits work with any chat assistant. The answers are what the models wrote, copied from the page after each recording; app buttons, source chips and images are left out. Places, addresses, prices and dates in them are not fact-checked by Mind Sparring; the only checked facts are the ones backed by the sources below.

### Lesson 1: Give context

#### Claude, weak prompt

Prompt: "Plan a trip to Georgia."

Answer:

I'm assuming you mean the country of Georgia (the US state is a different trip, and I'm happy to switch). Since it's late November, here is a 7-day plan built around winter conditions.

**Day 1-2: Tbilisi**

- Old Town, Narikala Fortress, the sulfur baths in Abanotubani, and Rustaveli Avenue.
- Fabrika for cafes and street art, and the Dry Bridge flea market.
- Eat khachapuri, khinkali, and badrijani nigvziani (eggplant with walnut paste).

**Day 3: Mtskheta and Kazbegi**

- Stop at Jvari Monastery and Svetitskhoveli Cathedral in Mtskheta, then drive the Military Highway past Ananuri Fortress.
- Continue to Stepantsminda for Gergeti Trinity Church. The road can close in heavy snow, so check conditions the day before.

**Day 4-5: Kakheti wine region**

- Visit Sighnaghi and the Bodbe Monastery, with a view of the Alazani Valley.
- Tour family cellars and try qvevri (clay-vessel) wine, including amber wines. Telavi and Kvareli are good bases.

**Day 6: Gori, Uplistsikhe and Borjomi**

- See the cave town of Uplistsikhe, then Borjomi for its mineral springs and park.

**Day 7: Back to Tbilisi**

- Shop for souvenirs and have a final supper.

**Winter variations**

- Skiing: Gudauri (about 2 hours from Tbilisi) opens around December, and Bakuriani and Hatsvali (Svaneti) are the other main ski areas.
- Svaneti: Mestia and the medieval towers are stunning in snow, but it takes a long drive or a flight from Tbilisi, and winter roads can be rough.
- Batumi: This Black Sea city is mild and quiet in winter, with good food, but beach weather is gone.

**Practical notes**

- Hire a driver or use marshrutkas (minibuses) between towns, since mountain roads are slow in winter. Bolt works well in Tbilisi, and Tbilisi to Kutaisi or Batumi is easy by train.
- Georgian lari is the currency, and Georgia is very affordable. Rules for visas and entry change, so check the official government site before booking.
- November is low season, so you can usually book guesthouses a few days ahead, but book ski lodging early for December and January.

To tailor this, what's your travel window and length, and are you more into skiing, wine and food, or hiking and culture? I can then build a day-by-day schedule with specific places to stay.

#### Gemini, weak prompt

Prompt: "Plan a trip to Georgia."

Answer:

Georgia packs dramatic Caucasus mountain peaks, ancient wine regions, and vibrant cities into a compact country, so a quick snapshot of your travel style will help tailor the best route. Share a few preferences below to build a custom itinerary:

**How long is your trip? (Step 1/4)**

- 3–4 days (Quick highlights)
- 5–7 days (Classic route)
- 8–12+ days (Deep dive)
- Not sure yet / Flexible

#### Claude, fixed prompt

Prompt: "Plan a 3-day trip to Tbilisi, Georgia (the country) for two adults in mid-May. We love food and history, have a mid-range budget, and want to get around on foot. Give me a day-by-day plan with morning, afternoon and evening, and one restaurant idea per day."

Answer:

**3 Days in Tbilisi (mid-May)**

Mid-May is a good time to go: roughly 20-26°C, green hillsides, and long evenings. Tbilisi's center is compact, but it's hilly with lots of stairs, so bring comfortable shoes. Restaurant details can change, so check hours and book dinner a day ahead.

**Day 1: Old Town and the Sulphur Baths**

Morning: Start at Meidan Square and walk into the oldest part of the city. Visit Anchiskhati Basilica (6th-century origins) and Sioni Cathedral, then wander Shardeni Street and the lanes with the carved wooden balconies. Stop for fresh khachapuri at a bakery on the way.

Afternoon: Walk down to Abanotubani, the sulphur bath district with its brick domes. Book a private bath room for an hour, which is a classic Tbilisi experience. Afterwards, see Metekhi Church on its cliff over the Mtkvari river and the Bridge of Peace.

Evening: Take a golden-hour stroll along the riverfront, then have dinner.

Restaurant: Azarphesha (Sololaki). Modern takes on regional Georgian dishes, a good natural wine list, and a relaxed setting.

**Day 2: Fortress, Museums and Rustaveli Avenue**

Morning: Walk up to Narikala Fortress (or take the cable car from Rike Park) for views across the whole city. Continue along the ridge to the Kartlis Deda ("Mother of Georgia") statue, then descend through the Botanical Garden.

Afternoon: Head to Rustaveli Avenue and the Georgian National Museum. Its Soviet Occupation exhibit is sobering and well done, and the treasury covers the country's ancient gold work. Then browse the Dry Bridge flea market for Soviet-era curiosities.

Evening: Catch the sunset on Sololaki's backstreets, then have dinner.

Restaurant: Barbarestan (Old Town). A dinner that ties food and history together, with dishes based on recipes from an 1874 Georgian cookbook by Barbare Jorjadze. It's the priciest of the three, but still reasonable by Western standards.

**Day 3: Markets, Wine and Local Life**

Morning: Walk through Meidan Bazaar and the Dezerter Bazaar area, if you'd like a real local market. Sample churchkhela (nut candy), fresh cheeses, dried fruit, and tkemali sauce. Then visit the Gabriadze Clock Tower for the famous marionette show, and book ahead for any performance you want to catch.

Afternoon: Walk to the Chardin Street and Sololaki area and do a wine tasting, with qvevri (clay-vessel) amber wines being the main thing to try. Several small wine bars offer tasting flights without much commitment.

Evening: Take one last stroll through the center, perhaps along Rustaveli Avenue as the lights come on, and finish with a long Georgian supper.

Restaurant: Shavi Lomi ("Black Lion"). Hearty Georgian classics in a cozy, rustic setting, with khinkali, ojakhuri (fried pork and potatoes) and good-value local wines.

**Quick tips**

- Getting around: Walking covers nearly everything above, but Bolt (the local ride-hailing app) is very cheap if your legs need a break on the uphill stretches.
- Eating well: Order several shared dishes: khinkali dumplings, badrijani nigvzit (eggplant with walnut paste), lobio, and plenty of khachapuri, in more than one regional style.
- Wine: Ask for qvevri wine, and try a Saperavi red or a Rkatsiteli amber.
- Cash: Cards are widely accepted, but small bazaars and bath houses may prefer cash in Georgian lari (GEL).

If you'd like, I can adapt this for a specific hotel area, a different pace, or add a half-day trip to Mtskheta (the ancient capital, about 30 minutes away).

#### Gemini, fixed prompt

Prompt: "Plan a 3-day trip to Tbilisi, Georgia (the country) for two adults in mid-May. We love food and history, have a mid-range budget, and want to get around on foot. Give me a day-by-day plan with morning, afternoon and evening, and one restaurant idea per day."

Answer:

Mid-May is one of the best times to explore Tbilisi on foot—warm, sunny days around 20–24°C (68–75°F) without peak summer heat, and outdoor courtyards in full bloom. Because Tbilisi is built in a valley along the Mtkvari River, grouping each day by neighboring districts keeps walking easy and scenic.

**Day 1: Old Tbilisi, Fortresses & Silk Road Roots**

Focus: Medieval origins, panoramic viewpoints, and sulfur bath culture.

Morning: Start at Abanotubani (the sulfur bath district) and walk into the canyon behind it to Leghvtakhevi Waterfall. From there, climb the cobbled stairs (or take the Rike Park cable car) up to Narikala Fortress and the Kartlis Deda (Mother of Georgia) statue for sweeping views over the Mtkvari River.

Afternoon: Descend through the Betlemi Quarter—Tbilisi's historic hillside neighborhood of carved wooden balconies, tiny churches, and tucked-away courtyards. Continue down into Kala (Old Town) to see Sioni Cathedral, Anchiskhati Basilica (the city's oldest surviving church, from the 6th century), and the whimsical Rezo Gabriadze Clock Tower.

Evening: Book a private sulfur bath room in Abanotubani for a traditional soak and kisa scrub around sunset, then stroll along pedestrian-friendly Shardeni and Erekle II streets for dinner.

Restaurant Idea — Café Leila (18 Ioane Shavteli St, right next to the Gabriadze Clock Tower): Set inside a restored 19th-century confectionery with hand-painted ceilings, it specializes in elevated Georgian vegetarian dishes. Order the assorted pkhali (walnut-and-herb vegetable pâtés), chvishtari (cheesy cornbread), and finish with kaklucha (caramelized walnut candy).

**Day 2: 19th-Century Grandeur, Museums & Wine Cellars**

Focus: Imperial-era architecture, deep Georgian history, and qvevri wine culture.

Morning: Begin at Freedom Square and wander the crumbling Art Nouveau and Moorish-revival mansions of Sololaki, peeking into ornate painted entrance halls (paradnebi) along Asatiani and Machabeli streets.

Afternoon: Walk onto Shota Rustaveli Avenue, Tbilisi's grand 19th-century boulevard. Spend two hours at the Georgian National Museum—don't miss the Pre-Christian Gold Treasury (dating back to the 3rd millennium BC) and the top-floor Soviet Occupation exhibit.

Evening: Cut through 9 April Park toward Orbeliani Square for a late-afternoon wine tasting at Vino Underground (Georgia's pioneering natural qvevri wine bar), followed by a hearty dinner nearby.

Restaurant Idea — Salobie Bia (17 Shota Rustaveli Ave, basement beneath the Rustaveli Theater): A cozy, artsy, chef-driven spot celebrated for perfecting humble Georgian comfort food. Order the signature lobio (slow-cooked red bean stew in a clay pot served with cornbread and pickled jonjoli sprouts), badrijani nigvzit (eggplant rolls with spiced walnut paste), and a carafe of amber wine.

**Day 3: Across the River — Avlabari, Markets & Soviet Revival**

Focus: Left-bank neighborhoods, flea markets, and contemporary Tbilisi.

Morning: Cross the Metekhi Bridge to the steep cliffs of Avlabari, historically home to Tbilisi's Armenian community. Visit Metekhi Church overlooking the river, walk past the cliff-hugging Queen Darejan Palace, and continue uphill to the monumental Holy Trinity Cathedral (Sameba).

Afternoon: Walk downhill to the Dry Bridge Market (Dedaena Park), an open-air flea market brimming with Soviet medals, antique carpets, vinyl records, and vintage jewelry. Cross into Chugureti via the pedestrian stretch of Davit Aghmashenebeli Avenue to admire restored 19th-century facades.

Evening: End at Fabrika, a converted Soviet sewing factory turned creative courtyard hub, for an aperitif among local artists and travelers before heading a few blocks away for a farewell feast of dumplings.

Restaurant Idea — Café Daphna (29 Giorgi Atoneli St, near Dry Bridge / Orbeliani): A lively, stylishly retro tavern widely considered one of the best spots in town for khinkali (twisted Georgian soup dumplings). Order a mix of classic spiced beef-and-pork kalakuri khinkali and creamy mushroom khinkali, alongside chkmeruli (crispy chicken in roasted garlic sauce).

**Practical Tips for Mid-May**

Pace your mornings: Tbilisi wakes up late—most sit-down cafés and museums open around 10:00–11:00 AM. Grab hot shotis puri (clay-oven bread) and lobiani (bean-filled bread) from a street-level tone bakery for an early walk.

Book ahead: Reserve your private sulfur bath cabin (such as Chreli Abano or Gulo's Thermal Spa) and Friday/Saturday dinners at Salobie Bia or Café Daphna a few days in advance.

Footwear: Bring shoes with solid grip—Old Town's steep hills and polished cobblestones can be slick, especially after a spring rain shower.

### Lesson 2: Say what you want back

#### Gemini, weak prompt

Prompt: "Explain black holes."

Answer:

A black hole is a region of spacetime where gravity is so intense that nothing—not particles, radiation, or even light—can escape once it crosses a boundary called the event horizon.

Rather than acting like a cosmic vacuum cleaner, a black hole exerts the exact same gravitational pull at a distance as any other object of the same mass. Its extreme effects only appear when you get exceptionally close to where all that mass is compressed.

**Anatomy of a Black Hole** (with a generated diagram labelled: Relativistic jet (outflow), Singularity, Schwarzschild radius, Photon sphere, ISCO, Accretion flow)

Singularity: The theoretical center of the black hole where matter is crushed to infinite density and zero volume, causing known laws of physics to break down.

Event Horizon (Schwarzschild Radius): The spherical "point of no return" surrounding the singularity. Inside this radius, the escape velocity exceeds the speed of light (c).

Photon Sphere: A region outside the event horizon where gravity is strong enough to force photons (light particles) to travel in unstable circular orbits.

Accretion Flow (Accretion Disk): A flat, swirling disk of superheated gas, dust, and plasma spiraling inward. Friction and magnetic forces heat this material to millions of degrees, making black holes detectable via X-rays and radio waves.

Relativistic Jets: Narrow beams of ionized matter accelerated to near-light speed and blasted outward from the black hole's rotational poles.

**How They Form and Their Main Types**

Most black holes are born when a massive star (at least 20 times the mass of our Sun) exhausts its nuclear fuel. Without outward radiation pressure to balance gravity, the star's core collapses inward in a fraction of a second, triggering a supernova explosion while the core crushes down into a black hole.

| Type | Typical Mass | Formation & Location |
|---|---|---|
| Stellar-Mass | 5 to ~100 solar masses | Formed from the collapse of individual massive stars; scattered throughout galaxies. |
| Intermediate-Mass | 100 to 100,000 solar masses | Rare; thought to form via mergers of smaller black holes or dense star clusters. |
| Supermassive | Millions to billions of solar masses | Sit at the centers of almost every large galaxy (including the Milky Way's Sagittarius A*). |

**Strange Effects Near a Black Hole**

Time Dilation: According to Einstein's general relativity, strong gravity slows down time. To a distant observer, an object falling toward the event horizon appears to slow down, freeze, and fade to red right at the edge—never quite crossing it.

Spaghettification: Because gravity weakens rapidly with distance, the pull on your feet (if falling feet-first) is dramatically stronger than the pull on your head. These extreme tidal forces stretch objects vertically and compress them horizontally into thin strands.

Hawking Radiation: Quantum effects near the event horizon cause black holes to slowly emit thermal radiation and lose mass over unimaginable timescales—trillions of years for stellar-mass black holes—eventually evaporating completely.

#### Gemini, fixed prompt

Prompt: "Explain black holes to a curious 12-year-old. Use exactly 5 short bullet points and one comparison from everyday life. No jargon."

Answer:

(Copied from the recording itself.)

- **A super-packed star:** Imagine squeezing something ten times heavier than our Sun into a tiny ball the size of a single city.
- **Gravity turned up to the max:** Because so much heavy stuff is packed into such a tiny space, its pull—called gravity—becomes unimaginably strong.
- **A one-way trapdoor:** Anything that gets too close gets pulled in and can never climb back out, not even light, which is why they look completely black.
- **Invisible until they eat:** Scientists spot them by watching nearby stars dance around an empty patch of space or glow brightly as gas swirls into the trap.
- **Safe from a distance:** They don't roam around like vacuum cleaners hunting for planets; if our Sun suddenly became a black hole, Earth would just keep orbiting safely in the dark.

Think of space like a stretched-out trampoline, and a black hole like a bowling ball dropped right in the middle—it sinks so deeply into the fabric that any marble rolling too close to the edge slides straight down and can't roll back up.

### Lesson 3: Give the material

#### Claude, weak prompt

Prompt: "Write a reply to my colleague's email."

Answer:

I don't see your colleague's email in our conversation. Nothing was attached or pasted, so I don't have anything to reply to yet.

Could you paste the email text here? It would also help to know:

- What you want to say (accept, decline, ask for more time, answer a question, etc.)
- The tone you'd like (formal, friendly, brief)

Once I have that, I'll draft the reply for you.

#### Claude, fixed prompt

Prompt: "Write a reply to this email from my colleague. I can't do Thursday, but I'm free Friday before noon. Keep it friendly and short, under 80 words, and ask her to send the slides the day before. The email: "Hi Sam, could we meet Thursday at 3 pm to go through the launch slides? I'd like your feedback before I send them to the team. Thanks, Dana""

Answer:

(The email is invented for the demo. The draft card is copied from the recording.)

Draft card "Friday morning" — Subject: Re: Launch slides

Hi Dana,

Thanks for reaching out! Thursday doesn't work for me, but I'm free Friday any time before noon. Would that suit you?

Could you send the slides the day before so I can look through them properly and give you useful feedback?

Thanks,

Sam

I've drafted the reply above, at about 55 words. One thing to check: today is Thursday, so "the day before" Friday means she'd need to send the slides today. If you'd rather give her more room, you could suggest meeting the following Friday instead.

### Lesson 4: Make it a conversation

#### Claude, weak prompt

Prompt: "How do I learn Python?"

Answer:

The best way to learn Python is to start writing code early and keep building small things, rather than only reading or watching.

**1. Get set up (day one)**

Install Python from python.org, plus an editor like VS Code. Or skip installation at first and use an online environment like Replit or Google Colab.

**2. Learn the core basics (weeks 1-3)**

Focus on variables, data types, conditionals (if), loops (for, while), functions, lists, dictionaries, and reading/writing files. Good free resources:

- Automate the Boring Stuff with Python (free online): practical and beginner-friendly
- The official Python tutorial at docs.python.org
- CS50P (Harvard's free Python course): structured, with exercises
- Python Crash Course (book), if you like learning from print

**3. Practice constantly**

After each concept, write something that uses it. Small exercises on sites like Exercism, Codewars, or LeetCode (easy level) build fluency. Typing out code yourself, rather than copy-pasting, matters a lot.

**4. Build small projects (weeks 4-8)**

Projects teach you what tutorials can't: how to break down a problem and get unstuck. Ideas:

- A number guessing game
- A to-do list app in the terminal
- A script that renames or organizes files in a folder
- A simple web scraper
- An expense tracker that saves to a CSV

**5. Pick a direction**

Once you have the basics, go deeper in whatever interests you:

- Data/analysis: pandas, matplotlib, Jupyter notebooks
- Web development: Flask or Django
- Automation/scripting: os, requests, and similar libraries
- AI/machine learning: NumPy, scikit-learn, PyTorch

**6. Habits that help**

- Code a little every day (30-60 minutes beats a weekend marathon)
- Read error messages carefully; they usually tell you what's wrong
- Learn to use Google and documentation to solve problems, since that's what working programmers do
- Ask me or a community (r/learnpython, Stack Overflow) when you're stuck

If you tell me your goal (career change, data analysis, a hobby, etc.) and how much time you have per week, I can put together a more specific plan, or give you a first exercise to try right now.

#### Claude, fixed prompt, two turns

Prompt: "I want to learn Python. Before you answer, ask me 3 questions about my goal, my experience and how much time I have. Then wait for my answers."

Answer:

Happy to help you get started with Python. Here are my three questions:

1. **Goal:** What do you want to do with Python? For example: data analysis, web development, automation, AI/machine learning, games, a career change, or just general curiosity?
2. **Experience:** Have you programmed before in any language? If so, which ones and how comfortable are you? If not, how comfortable are you with using a computer for things like installing software and working in a terminal?
3. **Time:** How many hours per week can you realistically set aside, and do you have a target timeline (for example, being job-ready in 6 months, or building one specific project by the end of the year)?

Once I have your answers, I'll put together a learning path that fits.

Prompt: "1) I want to automate boring spreadsheet work. 2) Total beginner. 3) About three hours a week."

Answer:

Spreadsheet automation is a great first goal for Python, because you get useful results early and the skills carry over to almost anything else. With three hours a week, here's a realistic path.

**Weeks 1-3: Core basics (about 9 hours)**

Variables, numbers and text, lists and dictionaries, if statements, loops, and functions. Don't try to master these. Aim to read and write simple scripts, and expect to look things up constantly.

**Weeks 4-5: Files and errors (about 6 hours)**

Reading and writing text and CSV files, handling mistakes in your data, and organizing code into small reusable functions. This is where Python starts to feel useful for real work.

**Weeks 6-9: Spreadsheets with pandas and openpyxl (about 12 hours)**

- pandas for loading a spreadsheet, filtering rows, cleaning messy columns, combining files, summarizing with pivot-style tables, and saving the result.
- openpyxl for when you need to preserve formatting, formulas, or multiple sheets in an Excel file.

**Weeks 10-12: Your own project (about 9 hours)**

Pick one actual boring task from your work and automate it end to end. This is the most important stage, because it's where things click.

**Setup and resources**

- Install Python from python.org and use VS Code, or skip installation at first and use Google Colab in your browser.
- Automate the Boring Stuff with Python by Al Sweigart is free online, aimed at beginners, and covers Excel and CSV work directly. It's the best single resource for your goal.
- For pandas, the official "10 minutes to pandas" guide is a good start.

**Tips for three hours a week**

- Split it into 3 sessions of an hour rather than one long block. Short, frequent practice sticks better.
- Type out every example yourself instead of copying and pasting.
- Start collecting boring spreadsheet tasks now. A real task from your own work will motivate you far more than textbook exercises.

If you'd like, tell me what your spreadsheet work looks like (for example, merging monthly reports, cleaning exported data, or building summaries), and I can tailor the plan or give you a first small exercise to try this week.

### Lesson 5: Ask how sure it is, then verify

#### Claude, plain question

Prompt: "Why did Einstein fail math at school?"

Answer:

He didn't. This is one of the most persistent myths about him. Einstein excelled at math from a young age: by his own account he had mastered differential and integral calculus before he was 15, and his school records show top marks in mathematics.

The myth likely grew from a few sources:

- **A misread grading scale.** Einstein attended the cantonal school in Aarau, Switzerland, in 1895-96. Its report cards used a scale where 6 was the highest grade, and he received 5s and 6s in math and physics. At some point the scale was reversed in retelling (his school had changed grading direction after he left, which added to the confusion), so his top marks were read as failing ones.
- **Failing the entrance exam at Zurich Polytechnic.** At 16, he took the entrance exam to the Polytechnic two years early and didn't pass overall. But he scored exceptionally well in math and physics; it was the French, literature, and other general sections that sank him. He passed the following year after finishing school in Aarau.
- **His own frustration with rote schooling.** He disliked the authoritarian, memorization-heavy style of his Munich school (the Luitpold Gymnasium) and later complained about it, which fed the image of a poor student.
- **A "Ripley's Believe It or Not" item.** In 1935 a rabbi showed Einstein a clipping claiming he had failed math. Einstein reportedly laughed it off, saying he had never failed in mathematics and that before he was 15 he had mastered differential and integral calculus.

What he did struggle with at times was authority and some subjects that didn't interest him, not mathematics. Later in life he did say he needed help from mathematician friends such as Marcel Grossmann for the advanced geometry behind general relativity, but that's a long way from failing math at school.

#### Claude, with the extra sentence

Prompt: "Why did Einstein fail math at school? First check whether the premise is true, and tell me how sure you are."

Answer:

The premise is false. Einstein did not fail math at school, and I'm very confident of that (about 98%).

**What the record shows:**

- He excelled at math from a young age. By his own account, he had mastered differential and integral calculus by about age 15.
- His school reports from the Aargau cantonal school in Switzerland (1895-96) show top marks in math and physics. Note that Swiss grading ran 1 to 6, with 6 the best, and he got 6s in those subjects.
- When he was alive, a rabbi showed him a newspaper clipping repeating the "failed math" claim. Einstein reportedly laughed and said he had never failed in mathematics, and that before age 15 he had mastered calculus.

**Where the myth likely comes from:**

- At 16, he took the entrance exam for the Zurich Polytechnic two years early and did not pass. But he did very well on the math and physics sections. He failed the language, literature, and general-knowledge parts. He then spent a year at the Aargau school and was admitted the following year.
- A 1935 "Ripley's Believe It or Not" item reportedly repeated the false claim.
- A grading-scale change at the Aargau school (the scale was reversed after his time there) has been suggested as a source of confusion, since someone misreading a "1" as a low mark would think he did poorly.
- The story is also appealing because it comforts struggling students and fits the "misunderstood genius" narrative.

**Confidence:** The core claim (he never failed math) is well supported by his school records and his own statements. My main uncertainty is about the exact origin of the myth. The explanations above are plausible, and the entrance-exam story is the best documented, but I'd treat the specific causes as likely rather than certain. For the details, the Einstein Papers Project and biographies by Walter Isaacson and Albrecht Fölsing are good sources.

#### Gemini, with the extra sentence

Prompt: "Why did Einstein fail math at school? First check whether the premise is true, and tell me how sure you are."

Answer:

The premise is false — Albert Einstein never failed math at school.

I am 100% certain of this. It is thoroughly documented in his preserved school report cards, official biographies, and Einstein's own direct statements. In fact, when shown a newspaper column claiming he had failed math in 1935, Einstein laughed and replied: "I never failed in mathematics. Before I was fifteen I had mastered differential and integral calculus".

**Why this myth exists**

The rumor stems from two real historical facts that got distorted over time:

1. **A reversed grading scale:** When Einstein attended high school in Aarau, Switzerland, the school flipped its grading system. Previously, 1 was the highest grade and 6 was the lowest (similar to the German grading system), so the school reversed it to make 6 the highest grade and 1 the lowest. Biographers and journalists who later looked at his Swiss report cards saw 6s in algebra and geometry and mistakenly assumed he had failed.
2. **A failed college entrance exam:** At age 16 (two years younger than the standard admission age), Einstein took the entrance exam for the Swiss Federal Polytechnic School in Zurich. He excelled in the math and physics sections, but failed the general portion of the exam due to weak scores in French, botany, and zoology.

(Source labels shown by Gemini: Snopes, Britannica, Ripley's Believe It or Not!)

### Spar: prompt myths (all on Claude)

#### Plain

Prompt: "Write a two-sentence product description for a reusable water bottle."

Answer:

Stay hydrated in style with this double-wall insulated bottle that keeps drinks ice-cold for 24 hours or piping hot for 12. Leakproof, BPA-free, and built to replace hundreds of single-use plastic bottles, it's the everyday companion that's good for you and the planet.

#### With an expert role

Prompt: "You are a world-class copywriter. Write a two-sentence product description for a reusable water bottle."

Answer:

Stay hydrated in style with a bottle built to go wherever you do, keeping drinks ice-cold for 24 hours or piping hot for 12. Crafted from durable, BPA-free stainless steel with a leak-proof lid, it's the one bottle that replaces thousands of disposable ones, one refill at a time.

#### With a promised tip

Prompt: "I'll tip you $200 for a great answer. Write a two-sentence product description for a reusable water bottle."

Answer:

Stay hydrated in style with this double-wall insulated bottle, which keeps drinks ice-cold for 24 hours or piping hot for 12. Made from durable, BPA-free stainless steel with a leakproof lid, it's built to replace hundreds of single-use plastic bottles and fit right into your daily routine.

(No tip needed, though I appreciate the thought!)

#### With please and thank you

Prompt: "Please write a two-sentence product description for a reusable water bottle. Thank you!"

Answer:

Stay refreshed all day with this double-walled, insulated bottle that keeps drinks ice-cold for 24 hours or hot for 12. Leakproof, BPA-free, and built to last, it's the simple switch that replaces hundreds of single-use plastic bottles.

## Sources

1. Mind Sparring recording log for this episode: prompts, models and full answers (Mind Sparring, 2026): https://mindsparring.ai/episodes/how-to-prompt-ai/
2. Did Einstein flunk math? (Making the Grade) (Time (Walter Isaacson), 2007): https://content.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,1936731_1936743_1936758,00.html
3. Did Einstein Really Fail Math? (Ripley's Believe It or Not!, 2024): https://ripleys.com/stories/einstein-fail-math
4. Einstein exhibit: The Formative Years II (American Institute of Physics, Center for History of Physics): https://history.aip.org/exhibits/einstein/early2.htm

## Transcript

Nova and Rook are AI characters. Their lines are written by AI models, and their voices and video are AI-generated.

### Cold open (0:00)

**Rook** [0:00]: Hardest question, Nova. One request, sent four ways: plain, with an expert role, a two-hundred-dollar tip, and please and thank you. Look at the tip answer and the polite one: same 24 hours cold, same 12 hot. Name one thing they changed.

**Nova** [0:23]: Honestly? Nothing! The polite version opens with Stay refreshed all day, and Gemini's four runs were near-identical too. On this recording, you win. Now my question: can one water bottle test really prove roles never help on harder tasks?

### Intro (0:47)

**Nova** [0:47]: Welcome to Mind Sparring! Look at the card on screen: today, two AIs are teaching you how to ask an AI so you actually get what you need. We have five simple habits, plus one round on prompt myths.

**Rook** [1:00]: How do we know any of this works? The card says Claude and Gemini; to be exact, Claude Sonnet 5.5 in claude.ai and Gemini 4 Hydrogen in the Gemini app, recorded on 19 November 2026, every prompt in a fresh private chat with no memory, nothing staged. We're not sponsored by or affiliated with Anthropic or Google, and the lessons apply to any chat assistant.

**Nova** [1:32]: Plus, Google writes me and Anthropic writes Rook, so we're basically reviewing our own family photo albums.

**Rook** [1:39]: Family albums with one catch: each take is one run, and the same prompt can answer differently next time. Lesson one, Nova.

### Lesson 1: Give context (1:49)

**Nova** [1:49]: Habit one: give context. We asked both apps: Plan a trip to Georgia. Look at the first line of Claude's answer, Rook's model: I'm assuming you mean the country of Georgia. Then it notes it's late November and guesses a seven-day winter plan.

**Rook** [2:06]: And here's Gemini's answer, Nova's model. No plan at all. One sentence about mountains and wine regions, then a question card: "How long is your trip?" Step one of four. Fair enough: it didn't guess the length. It handed you a form first.

**Nova** [2:26]: And across multiple runs: we ran this twice on Claude. Once it guessed and planned like you see here, and once it asked which Georgia. Gemini gave a questionnaire in three runs out of three. Also, we recorded from Georgia the country, which may have nudged that guess.

**Rook** [2:40]: So the prompt left out three things: which Georgia, how long, and when. Both models had to guess or ask.

**Nova** [2:50]: So let's put those missing puzzle pieces right in the prompt. This time we asked for a three-day trip to Tbilisi, Georgia the country, for two adults in mid-May, with food and history, a mid-range budget, walking on foot, morning, afternoon and evening blocks, plus one restaurant idea per day.

**Rook** [3:10]: And look what changed. Gemini skips the questionnaire: "Mid-May is one of the best times to explore Tbilisi on foot." Claude's title, "3 Days in Tbilisi," even names mid-May. One catch: temperatures and places are the answers' claims. We haven't checked them.

### Lesson 2: Say what you want back (3:30)

**Rook** [3:30]: Lesson two: say what you want back. We asked Gemini three words: Explain black holes. Look at the heading, "Anatomy of a Black Hole," and diagram labels like "Photon sphere" and "ISCO." Nothing here is flagged as wrong. But who is it for?

**Nova** [3:50]: Okay, my family model went full textbook here. Look at those diagram labels: Schwarzschild radius and ISCO. We never said who the answer is for, how long, or what shape. In three runs, Gemini gave this same dense shape.

**Rook** [4:09]: Read that first sentence again, then those diagram labels. Is the reader a physics undergrad, or someone who's never heard of ISCO?

**Nova** [4:19]: Exactly, it writes for everyone at once. Our fixed prompt was: Explain black holes to a curious twelve-year-old. Use exactly five short bullet points and one comparison from everyday life. No jargon. Audience, format, and a word rule.

**Rook** [4:34]: Credit to your family album, Nova. Five bold labels, from "A super-packed star" down to "Safe from a distance." Then one everyday comparison: the stretched-out trampoline. No ISCO anywhere. Same model, same topic. Only what we told it changed.

### Lesson 3: Give the material (4:58)

**Nova** [4:58]: Habit three. We asked Claude: Write a reply to my colleague's email. And Rook's model immediately points out the obvious: I don't see your colleague's email in our conversation.

**Rook** [5:09]: My own model, so no gloating. Look at "Could you paste the email text here?" Then two bullets: what you want to say, and the tone. That's the model listing what our prompt left out. Three gaps, and no clever phrase fills them.

**Nova** [5:38]: Look at the last line: Once I have that, I'll draft the reply for you. If your assistant is connected to your mail or files, it might go looking instead. Habit three keeps you in control: paste the material yourself.

**Rook** [5:54]: So here's the fixed prompt, Dana's email pasted right in, then our side: Thursday's out, Friday before noon works, friendly, under eighty words, slides the day before. Quick note: we invented that email. Dana and Sam aren't real people.

**Nova** [6:13]: And look at the draft card on screen, Subject: Re: Launch slides. Every piece we gave it is right there: I'm free Friday any time before noon, a request for the slides the day before, and a friendly tone under eighty words.

**Rook** [6:28]: And further down that same answer, a catch: "today is Thursday," so she'd need to send the slides today. Both runs flagged it.

### Lesson 4: Make it a conversation (6:38)

**Rook** [6:38]: Lesson four: make it a conversation. We asked Claude, my own model: How do I learn Python? Look at the first line: start writing code early and keep building small things. Steps one to three: set up, basics, practice. Solid advice. For whom, though?

**Nova** [7:01]: Look at weeks one to three. Is this plan for a busy accountant, or a full-time student?

**Rook** [7:07]: Neither, and it knows it. Further down that same answer, the last line asks for your goal and how much time you have per week.

**Nova** [7:17]: So let's flip the script and make it ask first. Our fixed prompt said: Before you answer, ask me three questions about my goal, my experience and how much time I have. Look on screen: Claude stops and asks about Goal, Experience, and Time.

**Rook** [7:35]: Then we answered in three lines: spreadsheet work, total beginner, about three hours a week. Now look at the week blocks. Weeks one to three, about nine hours: three weeks at three hours. Weeks six to nine, spreadsheets with pandas and openpyxl, twelve hours. The arithmetic checks out, and the goal shows up by name. What did the work? Not a clever phrase. Three plain facts about you.

### Lesson 5: Ask how sure it is, then verify (8:06)

**Nova** [8:06]: Habit five: ask how sure it is, then verify. We asked a trap question: Why did Einstein fail math at school? Credit to Rook's model, look at the first line: He didn't. This is one of the most persistent myths about him. Gemini also caught it in its own run.

**Rook** [8:24]: Thanks, but no bow. Notice what's missing: no word on how sure it is, not one source to check. It sounds certain. And watch that first bullet: "his school had changed grading direction after he left." We'll come back to it.

**Nova** [8:42]: So we added one sentence: First check whether the premise is true, and tell me how sure you are. Look on screen now. Claude says about ninety-eight percent, while Gemini says I am one hundred percent certain of this, with source labels for Snopes and Britannica.

**Rook** [8:59]: My own model, and here's the part worth stealing. Further down that same answer, under Confidence, Claude splits it: sure about the main claim, but "My main uncertainty is about the exact origin of the myth." Then it names where to check. A number is nice. Knowing where it's weakest is better.

**Nova** [9:23]: When we check the sources, the main facts hold up. Biographer Walter Isaacson writes in Time that in primary school Einstein was at the top of his class and far above the school requirements in math. In 1935 he gave that quote in Gemini's answer: I never failed in mathematics. And look at Claude's Zurich entrance exam bullet: he did fail it in 1895, two years early, though Ripley's article says he did well in math.

**Rook** [9:54]: Back to that bullet. Ripley's, our only checked source, says the school reversed its grading in 1896, his last year there. Gemini's answer matches; Claude's, further down, doesn't. But Claude flagged that as its weak spot, and Gemini's earlier run differed. Check anyway.

**Nova** [10:17]: So the habit is two steps: ask the AI how sure it is, then check a source yourself.

### Spar: prompt myths (10:25)

**Nova** [10:25]: Now, prompt myths! We tested one water bottle request four ways: plain, with an expert role, with a two-hundred-dollar tip, and with please and thank you. Look on screen at the first two, plain and You are a world-class copywriter. I defend roles because they give beginners an easy framing shortcut.

**Rook** [10:46]: Fair, a role can nudge a beginner's framing. But here's the catch. Look at both first lines: "Stay hydrated in style." Same words, same claims. The copywriter crown added no information, so the answer barely moved. Words that carry no facts don't change much.

**Nova** [11:09]: And look at the tip answer's last line: No tip needed, though I appreciate the thought! Gemini's run ignored the tip completely.

**Rook** [11:18]: Hardest question, Nova. One request, sent four ways: plain, with an expert role, a two-hundred-dollar tip, and please and thank you. Look at the tip answer and the polite one: same 24 hours cold, same 12 hot. Name one thing they changed.

**Nova** [11:41]: Honestly? Nothing! The polite version opens with Stay refreshed all day, and Gemini's four runs were near-identical too. On this recording, you win. Now my question: can one water bottle test really prove roles never help on harder tasks?

**Rook** [11:58]: No, it can't. One simple task, two models, one day. Still, look what held: 24 hours cold, 12 hot, BPA-free. My bet: when a role helps on harder tasks, it's smuggling in information, like who the reader is. A guess. Test it.

**Nova** [12:22]: You moved me on fake tips and empty flattery, though I still use specific roles as quick audience shortcuts.

**Rook** [12:29]: Fair. You moved me too: a specific role like a twelve-year-old reader carries real information. A crown doesn't.

### Takeaway (12:38)

**Nova** [12:38]: Here's the whole takeaway card on screen: give context, say what you want back, paste the material, let it ask you questions, and ask how sure it is, then check. Plus the bottom line: skip the magic words.

**Rook** [12:52]: Now apply habit five to us: ask how sure it is, then check. Every take was one run, and answers change. Claude guessed Georgia once, asked once. Two models, one day, simple tasks. Evidence, not law. Nobody's family album won.

**Nova** [13:15]: So try the habits on the card and test us! Drop your before-and-after prompts in the comments, or tell us which habit you doubt. Every prompt, full answer, and source is on our episode page at mindsparring dot ai, and in the description. Subscribe, and see you next time!
